It Could Have Been Her by Lisa Jewell: An In-Depth Review

 

Lisa Jewell has built a reputation as one of the most reliable names in psychological suspense. Over the past decade, she has delivered a series of bestselling thrillers that blend domestic drama, layered mysteries, and deeply flawed yet compelling characters. With It Could Have Been Her, Jewell returns with another dark and atmospheric tale that explores buried secrets, long-forgotten trauma, and the way the past can unexpectedly resurface decades later.

Scheduled for release in June 2026, It Could Have Been Her is a suspenseful mystery that combines a missing person case with a haunting personal history. Fans of Jewell's previous novels will find many of the elements that have made her work so popular, including strong characterization, multiple layers of mystery, and a steadily escalating sense of unease.

Overview

The novel follows Jane Trevally, a woman whose life takes an unexpected turn when she discovers a small white terrier wandering alone. The dog had apparently been with a teenage girl who has now gone missing. Determined to help, Jane decides to return the dog to its registered owner in London.

What begins as a simple act of kindness quickly becomes something far more sinister.

The destination is a run-down house known as Thornwood, located in a secluded corner of Hampstead. The moment Jane arrives, she realizes she has encountered this house before. Twenty-five years earlier, she experienced a terrifying event connected to the property, one that has remained buried in her memory ever since.

As Jane investigates the disappearance of the teenager and uncovers disturbing details about the people connected to Thornwood, she is forced to confront the darkest parts of her own past.

Story and Plot

One of the most intriguing aspects of the novel is its premise. The discovery of a lost dog serves as the catalyst for a much larger mystery involving missing persons, hidden identities, and decades-old secrets.

Jewell has always excelled at creating stories that begin with seemingly ordinary circumstances before gradually revealing something far more disturbing underneath. The opening setup immediately generates questions:

• What happened to the missing teenager?
• Why does Jane recognize the house?
• Who are the people living there?
• What secrets have been hidden for decades?

The novel appears to blend a contemporary missing-person investigation with a gothic-style mystery rooted in the past. This combination gives the story a broader scope than a standard thriller and allows Jewell to explore multiple timelines and interconnected mysteries.

The gradual uncovering of long-buried truths is one of the author's greatest strengths, and this novel appears perfectly suited to that style.

Atmosphere

Atmosphere has become one of Jewell's defining characteristics as a writer, and It Could Have Been Her looks to continue that tradition.

The mysterious house at Thornwood functions almost like a character itself. Isolated, secretive, and filled with unsettling memories, it creates a sense of dread long before any major revelations occur.

The setting evokes many classic gothic thriller elements:

• An old house with a troubled history.
• Characters haunted by the past.
• Hidden family secrets.
• Psychological tension.
• A lingering sense that something is terribly wrong.

Rather than relying on action sequences or excessive violence, Jewell builds suspense through uncertainty and emotional tension. Readers are encouraged to question what they know and whom they can trust.

Characters

Jane Trevally

Jane serves as the emotional center of the novel. Unlike many thriller protagonists who are professional investigators or law enforcement officers, Jane is an ordinary person pulled into extraordinary circumstances.

Her personal connection to Thornwood immediately makes her more interesting than a typical mystery protagonist. She is not simply trying to solve someone else's problem; she is confronting unresolved events from her own life.

This personal stake gives the story greater emotional depth and raises the tension because every discovery has consequences for Jane herself.

Supporting Characters

Jewell has consistently demonstrated an ability to create memorable supporting characters who feel authentic rather than existing merely to move the plot forward.

The mysterious occupants of Thornwood appear particularly compelling. The man who answers the door seems evasive and suspicious, while the appearance of a haunted-looking woman inside the house raises even more questions.

As with many Jewell novels, readers can expect that nearly every character will have secrets of their own.

Themes

The Past Never Truly Disappears

One of the central themes appears to be the lasting impact of past decisions and experiences.

Jane's return to Thornwood forces her to revisit events she thought were long behind her. The story suggests that unresolved trauma has a way of resurfacing, often when it is least expected.

Identity and Survival

The title itself, It Could Have Been Her, hints at questions of fate, identity, and alternate outcomes. The idea that a person's life might have unfolded differently under slightly different circumstances appears to be woven throughout the narrative.

Secrets and Deception

Like many of Jewell's best novels, the story revolves around hidden truths. Characters conceal information from each other, and the mystery unfolds through layers of deception that gradually peel away.

Writing Style

Lisa Jewell's writing style remains one of her greatest assets.

Her prose is accessible without being simplistic. She writes with enough detail to create vivid scenes while maintaining a pace that keeps readers turning pages.

Her chapters are often structured around small revelations and cliffhangers, making it difficult to stop reading. This technique has made many of her previous novels popular among thriller fans who enjoy binge-reading.

Jewell also excels at balancing character development with plot progression. Readers become invested in the people involved, not just the mystery itself.

Comparison to Previous Lisa Jewell Novels

Fans of the author's earlier work will likely find familiar elements here.

Readers who enjoyed:

• Then She Was Gone
• The Family Upstairs
• The Night She Disappeared
• None of This Is True

will likely appreciate the combination of psychological suspense, missing-person mystery, and dark family secrets found in this novel.

The return of Jane Trevally, a character who previously appeared in Don't Let Him In, adds an interesting layer for longtime readers while still allowing new readers to approach the story as a standalone thriller.

Strengths

• Intriguing mystery premise.
• Atmospheric setting.
• Strong psychological suspense.
• Emotionally invested protagonist.
• Multiple layers of secrets and revelations.
• Gothic thriller elements.
• Signature Lisa Jewell storytelling style.

Potential Drawbacks

• Readers seeking fast-paced action may find the story more character-driven than action-oriented.
• The gradual buildup of suspense may feel slow to readers who prefer immediate thrills.
• Complex mysteries with multiple layers require careful attention to detail.

For most Lisa Jewell fans, however, these qualities are likely to be strengths rather than weaknesses.

Final Verdict

It Could Have Been Her appears poised to become another standout addition to Lisa Jewell's growing catalog of psychological thrillers. The combination of a missing-person mystery, a haunting house with a dark history, and a protagonist forced to confront her own past creates an irresistible setup.

Jewell's ability to blend emotional depth with suspense has made her one of the most successful thriller writers working today, and this novel seems to showcase many of the qualities that readers have come to expect from her work.

For fans of psychological suspense, domestic thrillers, and mysteries built around long-buried secrets, It Could Have Been Her looks like a compelling and highly anticipated read.

Rating: 4.5/5 Stars

A gripping psychological thriller that combines mystery, atmosphere, and emotional depth into a story that promises plenty of twists and an unforgettable journey into the shadows of the past.

Find "It Could Have Been Her" On Amazon!

The Widow: A Novel by John Grisham – Full Review

John Grisham’s upcoming release, The Widow, marks another evolution in his long and celebrated career as a master of legal fiction. Scheduled for publication on October 21, 2025, this novel dives into familiar Grisham territory—lawyers, moral compromise, and small-town secrets—but adds a fresh twist: it’s his first true whodunit.

Overview

The Widow introduces readers to Simon Latch, a struggling small-town lawyer in rural Virginia. Simon is drowning in debt, facing marital strain, and feeling the weight of professional failure. His life changes when Eleanor “Netty” Barnett, an aging widow, walks into his office wanting to rewrite her will. She hints at a hidden fortune—investments and assets her stepchildren know nothing about—and Simon sees a way to solve his financial problems once and for all.

But when Netty suddenly dies under mysterious circumstances, everything spirals out of control. Simon becomes the prime suspect, accused of manipulating and possibly killing her for money. What follows is a tense, layered story that blends the suspense of a classic mystery with the emotional depth and realism of a legal thriller.

Plot Summary

The first part of the novel is a slow burn. Grisham takes his time building the world of the small Virginia town, introducing its people, and showing Simon’s desperation. He’s a man who once had promise but is now cornered by debt and bad choices. When Netty arrives, she seems like a lifeline—a wealthy, eccentric widow whose estate could rescue him from financial ruin.

As Simon takes on her case, he quickly realizes that not everything about Netty’s story adds up. Her supposed fortune is hidden through complicated investments, and her family’s hostility only adds more questions. When Netty dies after a car accident and subsequent hospitalization, Simon’s world collapses. What looks like bad luck quickly turns into a nightmare as the police begin piecing together circumstantial evidence against him.

As the investigation unfolds, Simon’s motives, finances, and personal life are scrutinized. He’s forced to conduct his own investigation to uncover the truth and prove his innocence. The courtroom scenes that follow are pure Grisham—taut, intelligent, and rooted in realism.

Themes

Moral Ambiguity and Desperation
The Widow explores how ordinary people can make terrible choices under pressure. Simon isn’t evil—he’s flawed, desperate, and human. Grisham paints a vivid picture of how desperation blurs ethical boundaries and how ambition can turn into self-destruction.

Deception and Secrets
Nearly every major character hides something. The novel’s suspense comes not only from the murder itself but from the lies, half-truths, and manipulations that surround it. Even Netty, long before her death, remains a mystery—what did she really want, and what was she hiding?

Small-Town Politics and Family Greed
Grisham captures small-town life perfectly: the gossip, the grudges, and the pressure of reputation. Netty’s family’s greed adds an emotional charge to the plot, and the tangled web of inheritance disputes becomes one of the book’s most compelling threads.

Justice and Redemption
At its heart, this is a story about redemption. Simon’s journey from morally compromised lawyer to someone fighting for truth and justice mirrors the redemption arcs in Grisham’s earlier works, but with a darker, more introspective tone.

Writing Style and Structure

Grisham’s writing here is confident and straightforward, with clean prose that moves the story along efficiently. The first half of the novel is deliberately paced, focusing on character development and atmosphere. Once the murder accusation lands, the story gains speed and intensity, pulling readers into the courtroom drama that Grisham executes so well.

He balances investigative sequences with legal realism, never losing sight of the emotional core. The dialogue is sharp, and the pacing in the second half keeps readers guessing until the very end. The story twists and turns without becoming convoluted, showing Grisham’s mastery at maintaining clarity even through complex legal and moral situations.

Characterization

Simon Latch is one of Grisham’s most layered protagonists in recent years. He’s not a heroic lawyer fighting for justice from the start; he’s a man teetering on the edge of failure and moral collapse. His development feels authentic as he learns hard lessons about integrity, trust, and survival.

Netty Barnett, while not present for the entire book, looms large over the story. Her secrets drive the plot, and her mysterious past keeps readers questioning what really happened long after she’s gone. The supporting characters—ranging from greedy relatives to suspicious townspeople—add depth and realism.

Strengths

The Widow’s greatest strength is its blend of genres. It combines the suspense of a murder mystery with the realism of a courtroom thriller. The legal details are sharp, but the novel’s heart lies in its psychological tension. The moral complexity of the characters keeps the story grounded and believable.

The book also benefits from Grisham’s signature understanding of small-town life and legal nuance. The dialogue and settings feel authentic, and the gradual buildup pays off with strong emotional and narrative momentum in the final act.

Weaknesses

Some readers may find the beginning slow, as Grisham carefully sets up his world and characters. While the pacing accelerates later, the early chapters might test those expecting immediate action. Additionally, while the mystery is compelling, seasoned readers of the genre might predict some of the twists before the conclusion.

Verdict

The Widow stands as one of Grisham’s most ambitious recent novels—a thoughtful blend of legal drama and mystery that explores human weakness, greed, and redemption. It may not reinvent the murder mystery genre, but it delivers a gripping, emotionally rich story with moral weight and suspenseful pacing.

Fans of Grisham’s earlier works like The Confession and The Testament will appreciate its blend of legal realism and ethical tension, while newcomers will find an engaging, well-constructed story with universal themes.

Final Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
A slow start gives way to a powerful, character-driven mystery that proves John Grisham still knows how to keep readers on edge while exploring the complicated choices that define us.

🕮Get The Widow On Amazon!🕮